I have been playing this app on and off ever since it came out, and as a die hard Pokémon fan, I have to say Im impressed with what this app has to offer. However I was taken aback when I could only pick between two trainers.
Of course you could argue that it didnt explicitly ask "are you a boy or a girl?" (something Im all too familiar with), and you can of course switch between the two, but something still felt... off. Now you might wonder why Im not critiquing the gameplay segment of this app. I feel like in this case (and in many others) inclusion comes first.
If you dont feel included (part of the actual experience, gameplay, etc), would you want to play the game? If you still choose to play, are you really a part of the gaming community? Are they (the game developers) actually interested in interacting with their fanbase? Or, are they seeing them, but prefer to not actually acknowledge them?
As someone who is nonbinary/genderqueer I was of course happy that I could change my presentation at will, however the fact that there are still only two options to choose from baffles me. If there was a third trainer, one where you could fully customize their appearance (neither male or female in appearance).
The clothing would not be gender locked, and the trainers base could be customized (neither strictly masculine or feminine. Kind of like a simplified sim).
I feel like this would empower people who actually feel this way. They would feel included and seen in a world that otherwise shuns and chooses to ignore us.
The Pokémon games have never really been truly inclusive. During the first generation, the player (regardless of their true gender [or a lack of]) were forced to pick a male trainer.
The second generation changed this, but it was only in the third game (Crystal) where players could then choose to play as a female character. Ever since then there have only been two options (for nearly 20 years).
I feel like this app presents a brand new opportunity for nonbinary/genderqueer players to be seen and to be acknowledged as actual members of the gaming community.